12 Best Natural Eye Creams: EWG Rated & Human Reviewed

Your easy reference list to the best non-toxic eye creams. Great for sensitive skin. Rated safe by the Environmental Working Group and reviewed by women who love them. Another great resource from Blissful Miss.

So you want great skin without getting cancer or throwing your hormones out of whack, right? Of course you do! Or perhaps your more concerned with finding a product that doesn't flare up your ubber sensitive skin.

Well, Blissful Miss has got you covered.

Anti-Aging, Dark Circles & More

In addition to being safe for your health, all of the products here boast one or all of the following benefits:

  • Anti-Aging
  • Dark Circles
  • Puffiness
  • Brightening
  • Sensitive Skin

Sensitive Skin

If you are struggling to find an eye cream that won't irritate your skin, chances are high there's one here you will love. It's unlikely that one specific eye cream will work for every person who suffers with irritated, sensitive skin, but this list narrows down your risk factor substantially since all of them contain rave reviews from women who finally found a product that works for their finicky eye area. Check out Avene Soothing Eye Contour Cream for a product specifically formulated to heal and soothe irritated skin. However, it is almost the only eye cream on this list that does not claim anti-aging benefits, reduction of dark circles, etc. So you might try one of the others here if you're looking for more in an eye cream.

How This Natural Eye Cream List Was Created

The Environmental Working Group

The Environmental Working Group (EWG) is a trusted organization that rates products according to their toxicity to the body. Each individual ingredient is listed for every product with the rating of that ingredient, along with what adverse affects it may have on the body. Products are given an overall rating from 1 to 10 with 1 being the safest and 10 the most toxic nastiness. 

To date there are 358 eye creams listed on EWG, and 77 of them have a safety rating of 1 or 2.

But how does one choose from the 77? Especially when so many are unfamiliar brands. And where can these products be found? 

Amazon Reviews

Blissful Miss narrowed down the 77 eye creams by compiling a list of only those found on Amazon. Everyone loves Amazon, right? And better yet, Amazon has thousands and thousands of reviews from people who have tested those eye creams for us. Therefore, the list was narrowed down further to only those eye creams with Amazon ratings of 4 stars or higher.

Disclaimer

The safety of products suggested by Blissful Miss is based on the Environmental Working Group rating system. This is not to say that every ingredient in and of itself is considered completely safe, but combined with several other safe ingredients receives a good rating by EWG. If you want to ensure every ingredient is up to your personal standards you are encouraged to read ingredient lists and do further research as you see fit.


The Blissful Miss List of Best Natural Eye Creams


EWG Rated - 1


  • EWG Rating - 1
  • Anti-Aging, Reduces Puffiness

Product Description

Weleda claims this antioxidant rich eye cream reduces the appearance of wrinkles by 23% after 28 days. It is fragrance-free cream, renews skin, reduces puffiness and protects the delicate eye area from damaging environmental elements.

Review Quotes

It has helped eliminate about 50% of the lines under and on the sides of my eyes. I love it and would definitely recommend it.
I love the WELEDA pomegranate series - it makes my skin firm and look good. I tried a couple other anti-aging cremes and lotions ... but I always come back - it is worth the money!

I love this cream. It has diminished the brown spots on my face, even though it doesn't advertise itself to do this. The consistency is perfect for the dry areas on my face but not oily. Worth every penny.


  • EWG - 1
  • Anti-Aging, Reduces Dark Circles and Puffiness

Product Description

Weleda claims this eye cream reduces dark circles and puffiness, as well as smoothing fine lines and wrinkles. Antioxidant-rich rosehip seed oil protects skin from damage.

Review Quotes

I'm in my late 40's and people always remark that I have beautiful skin and look like I'm in my 30's. I know this product is helping!

I don't think I could survive without my rose cream and the price was fantastic.

This eye cream is perfect! It is nicely hydrating & not too pricey--a little goes a long way. I have very sensitive skin & cannot tolerate fragrance. The rose scent is subtle & does not bother my chemically-sensitive self! I don't know why I try other eye creams because I always return to this one!


  • EWG - 1
  • Anti-Aging, Skin Brightener
     

Product Description

Naturally distilled organic cucumber extract is the age old eye care secret ingredient in Keys Eye Butter. Combined with pharmaceutical grade ingredients, this non-toxic product claims to soften eye tissue, reduce fine lines, and enhance skin. They say the glowing effect brightens and enhances skin, making it a great natural foundation for mineral eye makeup. I don't know about you, but I'd sure like to be more "glow-y"!

Review Quotes

I've been using it for about 6 months, day & night ... I'm 53, but have almost no visible lines around my eyes ... In just this short amount of time, its made a world of difference.

Really rich eye butter. A little goes a long way. I am sensitive to most everything (eczema & mild rosacea). So far, no problems at all. My under eye feels firmer when I put it on.

This eye cream is the BEST of the best and I have tried at least 20 different kinds.


  • EWG - 1
  • Anti-Aging, Soothes Sun Damage, All Skin Types

Product Description

Plant oils of sea buckthorn and pumpkin seed protect and firm skin while refining fine lines. The botanical blends leaves skin feeling soft, smooth and rejuvenated.

Amazon Reviews

I have ordered this cream twice now, and can't rave enough about it. I had dark circles and puffiness under my eyes. No more, and I get complements all the time telling me I look 10 to 15 years younger. What's not to love!

I was getting fine lines around my eyes and after a couple days of using the Sibu eye cream, I've noticed a huge difference. My lines are virtually gone. This eye cream loads your skin with moisture, but it isn't greasy. It absorbs immediately. This is by far one of the most effective eye creams that I've ever tried.

I had extreme dryness and flakiness around my eye and I tried every cream and ointment I could find. Sibu is the only one that helped. It also made my eyes look much better all around. Nice texture and easy to rub in.

  • EWG - 1
  • Anti-Aging, Sensitive Skin, Soothes Puffy Eyes, Multi-Use

Product Description

Many happy reviewers use this organic eye cream for their entire face and neck. One reviewer says it makes her eyelashes longer and fuller, and she uses it on her eyebrows as well. Another woman puts it on in the evening and "it does miracles by morning". Mary Ann first created skincare products for herself because nothing else worked on her sensitive skin, but the results were so wonderful for both her and her friends, she turned it into a business.

Review Quotes

I've bought so many of eye creams over the years (from Channel to Clinique and beyond) but this is by far THE BEST and what an incredible value! ... My eye wrinkles are melting away and that's a good thing when you're 61 years young!

Works amazingly well - my eyes were itchy and puffy and this cream cured them overnight - literally! I have very sensitive skin so it is hard to find face products I trust, but this cream is so gentle it doesn't even hurt if it gets in your eye.

It exceeded my expectations! I love the smell and feel (it's not oily). It seems to help with dark circles – I look less tired and feel prettier. I started using it on other areas of my face – seems to help clear up the little red veins around my nose.


  • EWG - 1
  • Anti-Aging, Antioxidants

Product Description

HollyBeth Organics Eye Cream claims to combat tired eyes with a velvety rich formula. Reduces the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles and infuses the skin with anti-aging antioxidants.

Review Quotes

I love this moisturizing eye cream and it's natural ingredients! It really does make a difference in my under-eye wrinkles and in the softness of my skin. It is also non-irritating and gentle.

My pale skin is prone to fine creases despite being careful about sun for years, but also very sensitive so I react to many cosmetics ... I've had great results in just 5 weeks with NO reactions ... Update: A year and a half since using this, I'm still thrilled with this product. Wouldn't use anything else!

Wonderful eye cream! I have tried lots of eye creams and this one is my favorite so far. It goes on very easily and spreads well around my eyes. I've been using it for over a week now and have noticed less redness (I'm a very fair blonde so redness under my eyes is obvious and common). A little goes a VERY long way so although it's expensive it will last a long time.


  • EWG - 1
  • Anti-Aging

Product Description  

This Herbal Choice eye cream is certified organic, so no worries about toxins here. Excellent for all skin types, the nourishing plant ingredients diminish the appearance of fine lines and offer long term youthful looking skin. They say the mild lavender scent dissipates without lingering. 

Review Quotes

Definitely helps to soothe, stimulate, moisturize and tighten sensitive under eye skin and minimizes fine lines. Totally recommend this product.

I love this eye cream it is very very hydrating! I apply at night and my skin still feels great in the morning. It beautifully plumped up my under eye skin and smoothed the lines.

This works great for me because I have sensitive eyes. This does not irritate my eyes at all and moisturizes my eye area very well.

I love this eye cream. The size is much larger than other eye creams I have used, it will last and last.


Nurture My Body Eye Cream

  • EWG - 1
  • Anti-Aging, Skin Brightener

Product Description  

This certified organic eye cream claims to reduce fine lines and improve firmness on sensitive skin. Shea butter and what they call "eyebright fusion" help diminish signs of premature aging. Many reviewers say a little goes a long way, with one estimating it would last her four months. This product comes with a 100% money back guarantee. Sweet!

Review Quotes

I have had problems finding an eye cream that reduces puffiness, without scent, that does not produce an allergic reaction. It is a great organic product for someone with sensitive skin and allergies.

This eye cream is very creamy and moisturizing and has helped improve under eye puffiness and seems to plump the skin all around my eyes and near the cheek area.

Very nice cream. Thick and moisturizing. Area around my eyes is very sensitive, and this is one of the very few creams that I can use. Highly recommend.


EWG Rated - 2


  • EWG - 2
  • Designed for Sensitive Skin, Healing, Soothing

Product Description  

Of all the eye creams on this list that work well for sensitive skin, this one seems top them all. While it makes no anti-aging claims, reviewers consistently boast at how nothing else has worked for their sensitive, easily irritated skin and/or how well it soothes and heals the affects of an allergic reaction.

Review Quotes

I had eye surgery and read that this cream was mild and used by many for healing. Not only did it aid in healing it is a perfect eyelid moisturizer alone and as a base for makeup. I will continue to use this amazing cream forever!

I had a serious eye allergy and my eyelids were extremely dried. This cream was the only one that soothes my eyes. It looks small but you don't need much and it goes a long way.

I had am allergic reaction to make-up & after reading all the great reviews, I had to try this product. I couldn't be happier, instantly it was like I put a cold compress on my eyes. The burning and itching went away, immediately. A small amount, goes a long way. 2 days and the irritation is gone. Highly recommend.


  • EWG - 2
  • Anti-Aging, Reduces Dark Circles

Product Description  

AHAVA says they use cutting edge, active ingredients that provide intense hydration and significant wrinkle reduction. Apparently 92% of a test group saw an improvement in radiance.

Review Quotes

This cream is very light but extremely moisturizing. I have noticed a difference in the fine lines around my eyes after just a few weeks use. I highly recommend it.

This is a wonderful eye cream. After just two days of nighttime application, I already see that the dark circles under my eyes basically non-existent and my eyes in general look brighter and less tired.

Love it because it works! Really makes lines disappear !


  • EWG - 2
  • Anti-Aging, Reduces Dark Circles

Product Description  

Lumene Time Freeze Eye Cream contains bioactive wild arctic lingonberry extract. Wow, that's a lot of words for one ingredient, but combined with quercetin, apparently provides visibly youthful, firmed and lifted skin. This product also claims to lighten dark circles. Sweet!

Review Quotes

Wears well even in hot humid weather. Looks good after sweating at the gym too. My daily go to. I can't live without it!

I love it I already started seeing the difference.

I recommend this eye cream to any woman of any age ... particularly those who are prone to milia. The lightweight formula seems to lessen, or eliminate, that scourge. 


  • EWG - 2
  • Anti-Aging, Reduces Puffy Eyes

Product Description  

Repair and rebuild skin while soothing puffy eyes and tightening fine lines with this gentle formulation of botanical ingredients.

Review Quotes

My skin has become dry around my eyes...this is an amazing product that hydrates and reduces the lines. I used Clinique's all about eyes Rich prior and this product took it's place. VERY pleased.

I could see an improvement with the fine lines under my eyes ... I did an experiment. After using the Borage eye cream for a while, I went back to one of my other brands ... The next day the lines were more pronounced. The following day I used the Borage eye cream and saw an immediate improvement.

Shikai eye cream it keeps my eyes so soft and wrinkle free with no side effects or redness ever.



EWG Is Doctor Recommended

Dr. Oz and Dr. Mercola both recommend The Environmental Working Group as a resource for finding safe products. So discover your bliss with a new safe and natural products, live well, and be fabulous!  

Written by Jenna Dawn
© Blissful Miss

Pin Me and Follow on Pinterest

YOUR EASY REFERENCE LIST TO THE BEST NON-TOXIC EYE CREAMS. GREAT FOR SENSITIVE SKIN. RATED SAFE BY THE ENVIRONMENTAL WORKING GROUP AND REVIEWED BY WOMEN WHO LOVE THEM. ANOTHER GREAT RESOURCE FROM BLISSFUL MISS.