9 Best Natural Eye Creams


The Research Has Been Done For You

We Make It Ridiculously Easy

Don't Compromise Your Health To Be Gorgeous

We Care about the Ingredients that Leach Into Your Beautiful Skin

Quickly Find a Safe Eye Cream You Love & Trust

Save Time, Brain Cells, and Money


Blissful Miss Easy Natural Product Guides

How To Find Your Perfect Eye Cream

Browse The List

Choose a Product

Get On With Your Life Already


What you put on your body soaks into your skin, goes into your blood stream and seeps into your organs


Blissful Miss Makes It Ridiculously Easy


Quickly and easily find a totally amazing and totally natural Eye Cream that will give you everything you want around your delicate eye area, with nothing you don't want leaching into your body. You don't have to memorize lists of toxic ingredients. You don't have to spend hours researching.

It’s easier than you think, because Blissful Miss has done the research for you. 

Find a Safe & Natural Eye Cream that Delivers

What does your skin need from an eye cream? It's all here.

  • Anti-Aging

  • Fine Lines & Wrinkles

  • Dark Circles

  • Brown Spots

  • Puffiness

  • Brightening

  • Healing

  • Sensitive Skin

Koru Flourish DIV.png

Why You Can Trust This List

1-Safe 123.jpg


The Environmental Working Group rates products according to their toxicity to the human body. Each Blissful Miss guide begins with products rated safe by EWG. Products are rated 1 through 10, with 1 being the safest.

2-Reviewed 123.jpg


EWG Safe products are then cross-referenced with human reviewers on Amazon, who have tried them, love them, and rated them with a super awesome 4 stars or higher. 

Your easy reference list to the best non-toxic eye creams. Great for sensitive skin. Rated safe by the Environmental Working Group and reviewed by women who love them. Another great resource from Blissful Miss.

EWG Rated - 1

Mary Ann's Naturals Eye Cream

EWG - 1

  • Anti-Aging

  • Reduce Wrinkles

  • Soothes Puffy Eyes

  • Multi-Use

Many happy reviewers use this organic eye cream for their entire face and neck. One reviewer says it makes her eyelashes longer and fuller, and she uses it on her eyebrows as well. Another woman puts it on in the evening and "it does miracles by morning". Mary Ann first created skincare products for herself because nothing else worked on her sensitive skin, but the results were so wonderful for both her and her friends, she turned it into a business. Yay for the rest of us!

Review Highlights

  • One "eye cream-trying-junkie" claims her eye wrinkles are "melting away" ... at 61 years young. Awesome!

  • A woman's itchy & puffy eye issue was cured overnight.

  • Another says it helps with dark circles, she look less tired, and it even helps clear up little red veins around her nose.

Keys Care Eye Butter Anti-Aging Eye Cream

EWG - 1

  • Anti-Aging

  • Skin Brightener

  • Reduce Fine Lines

Naturally distilled organic cucumber extract is the age old eye care secret ingredient in Keys Eye Butter. Combined with pharmaceutical grade ingredients, this non-toxic product claims to soften eye tissue and reduce fine lines. The glowing effect brightens and enhances skin, making it a great natural foundation for mineral eye makeup. I don't know about you, but I'd sure like to be more "glow-y"!

Review Highlights

  • At 53, one reviewer has almost no visible lines around her eyes after about 6 months of use.

  • Really rich eye butter. Under eye feels firmer. No sensitivity issues, including flare ups with eczema & mild rosacea.

  • One woman claims this eye cream is the "best of the best" and she has tried at least 20 different kinds.

Herbal Choice Mari Organic Eye Cream

EWG - 1

  • Anti-Aging

  • Plump Under Eye Skin

  • Soothe, Stimulate & Moisturize

This Herbal Choice eye cream is certified organic, so no worries about toxins here. Excellent for all skin types, the nourishing plant ingredients diminish the appearance of fine lines and offer long term youthful looking skin. They say the mild lavender scent dissipates without lingering. 

Review Highlights

  • Definitely helps to soothe, stimulate, moisturize and tighten sensitive under eye skin and minimizes fine lines.

  • Very very hydrating! Apply at night and skin still feels great in the morning. It beautifully plumps up under eye skin and smoothes the lines.

  • Great for sensitive skin, does not irritate eyes, moisturizes well and the large jar lasts a very long time.

Nurture My Body Eye Cream

EWG - 1

  • Anti-Aging

  • Reduce Fine Lines

  • Firm Skin

  • Skin Brightener

This certified organic eye cream claims to reduce fine lines and improve firmness on sensitive skin. Shea butter and what they call "eyebright fusion" help diminish signs of premature aging. Many reviewers say a little goes a long way, with one estimating it would last her four months. This product comes with a 100% money back guarantee. Sweet!

Review Highlights

  • One sensitive-skin reviewer had a hard time finding an eye cream that would reduce puffiness, was unscented with no allergic reaction. (But she did!)

  • Helps improve under eye puffiness, plumps skin around eyes and near the cheek area.

  • Thick & moisturizing. One of the few creams one reviewer can use for her very sensitive skin.

Naturopathica Argan & Peptide Wrinkle Repair Eye Cream

EWG - 2

  • Anti-Aging

  • Reduce Dark Circles

  • Reduce Fine Lines & Wrinkles

Plump up your eye area with this concentrated age-defying eye cream. Calm puffiness and reduce the appearance of fine lines, wrinkles and dark circles. Get all youthful with powerful Peptides, and refreshed with rejuventaing Argan and Edelwiss Plant Stem Cells. Reviewers say it’s the best eye cream they’ve ever used.

Review Highlights

  • A reviewer says her eyes have never looked this great even with the most expensive eye creams. Definitely the best eye cream she has ever used.

  • Another reviewer, who loves the easy to dispense tube, does a double take when she passes by the mirror!

  • Moisturizes the eye area without running or clogging pores.

EWG Rated - 2

Eau Thermale Avene Soothing Eye Contour Cream

EWG - 2

  • Healing, Soothing

  • Designed for Sensitive Skin

Of all the eye creams on this list that work well for sensitive skin, this one seems to top them all. While it makes no anti-aging claims, reviewers consistently boast at how nothing else has worked for their sensitive, easily irritated skin and/or how well it soothes and heals the affects of an allergic reaction.

Review Highlights

  • Aided in healing after eye surgery. The same reviewer said it was also a great moisturizer and base for makeup.

  • A woman with serious eye allergy and extremely dry eyelids says this eye cream soothes. You don' need much, because a little goes a long way.

  • Like putting a cold compress on the eyes after an allergic reaction to make-up. The burning & itching went away immediately. Irritation completely gone after 2 days.

Earth Science Azulene Eye Cream

EWG - 2

  • Anti-Aging

  • Fine Lines

  • Puffiness

  • Dark Circles

If you've got puffy eye issues, give this one a try. Reviewers say it works. This uber "wallet-friendly" eye cream contains Alpha Hydroxy Acids for super soft and moist skin, which in turn, minimizes those nasty fine lines.

Review Highlights

  • After 3 years of use, one reviewer reports that it works well to remove puffiness, dark circles & fine lines. It’s very cream & luxurious. Mmmmm!!!!

  • A user of 5 years says it really helps reduce the bags under her eyes. She uses it under makeup with a bit of powder so her eye makeup stays on.

  • "Outstanding eye cream!” says one ecstatic reviewer. Feels great upon application and does a great job of hydrating the area around your eyes.

Lumene ExCELLent Future Repairing Eye Cream

EWG - 2

  • Anti-Aging

  • 100% of Women Saw a Reduction in Wrinkle Appearance

Repair, Plump & Rejuvenate skin stem cells with Lumene’s Applexcell™compound. And while you’re at it, STOP and/or postpone the damage that’s lurking beneath the surface of your skin from ever turning into wrinkles. Nice! In a clinical study, every single woman reported a reduced appearance of wrinkles.

Review Highlights

  • One reviewer says they aren’t kidding with the “100% of women saw results” thing. She’s usually in the percentage that “doesn’t” get results, but is thrilled that she has seen quite a change in her eye area.

  • Several reviewers remark on an improvement in skin around the eye.

  • Softens skin and is not greasy.

Andalou Naturals Coconut Water Eye Lift Cream

EWG - 2

  • Quench Dry Skin with Coconut Water

Infuse the electrolyte goodness of Coconut Water into your parched skin to instantly hydrate and plump it up, girl! Add some skin-friendly enzymes and healing Vitamin C to the mix to brighten and smooth your skin, while reducing those pesky lines and wrinkles.  

Review Highlights

  • Makes a noticeable difference for a reviewer who “love, love, loves” this eye cream.

  • A woman who’s tried many eye creams says this one actually does seem to smooth out the fine lines around her eyes.

  • It’s a cross between a cream and a gel. Not too heavy. Does not irritate sensitive eyes.

PIN Me & Follow on Pinterest

Your easy reference list to the best non-toxic eye creams. Great for sensitive skin. Rated safe by the Environmental Working Group and reviewed by women who love them. Another great resource from Blissful Miss.

EWG Is Doctor Recommended

Dr. OzDr. Axe and Dr. Mercola all recommend The Environmental Working Group as a great resource for finding safe products like your new favorite Eye Cream. And they're doctors and all!

So discover your bliss with safe and totally bomb products, live well, and be fabulous!  


The safety of products suggested by Blissful Miss is based on the Environmental Working Group rating system. This is not to say that every ingredient in and of itself is considered 100% safe, but combined with several other non-toxic ingredients, that product receives a high rating by EWG. Any product on this list can be researched on the EWG Skin Deep Database for specific details of how each ingredient is rated and what the known concerns are, if any.

© Blissful Miss